I am going to answer a question form Tracey Brumlik:
Since your an expert and I'm just starting potty training #1...what should I do or not do?
To be honest, I cannot say there is one good way, nor is there a one size fits all solution to potty training.
My experience with potty training has been different with every child!
If I was going to give advice about party training this is what I would say:
- Potty training is gross!!!!!! It makes changing five poopy diapers a day seem pleasant.
- Everyone will be ready and willing to tell you the best way to potty train your child.
I am guilty of this. (Just ask my sister.)
- The truth: you know yourself and your child the best. Trust yourself the most on the matter.
Here are some things to consider before potty training:
- Do messes make you mad and stressed?
- What are some things you have had success using to encourage your child to either change a behavior or to do something new? (Examples: candy, time outs, promised gifts, sticker charts, a soft voice).
- How well does you child communicate his or her needs with you?
- Does your child care if he or she is messy or not?
This is what I generally do:
- I have my child try out the toilet to see what he or she will do. If the child knows what to do then great. If not, then I spend a day at home giving the child drinks and sitting by a potty chair until the child figures out what to do. Sometimes this just does not work. It depends on the child.
- When the child knows what to do, I take off the diaper and put on underwear. This works well if the child cares if he or she is messy, and if I can calmly handle cleaning up poopy pants and pee on everything. (Sometimes I am not ready for the mess when I think I am). If the child doesn't care or if I am finding that every potty mess is making me angry, it does not work.
- Next, I remind the child to use the bathroom every couple of hours.
- When the child is staying dry for a few days on reminders, I quit reminding and make the child tell me when he/she has to go.
- When the child is doing it all on his or her own, I flood him/her with praise over a few days and there after send him/her to timeout for accidents (being cautious about possible UTI"s)
When I can't get the child to go in the toilet, or when I find myself flipping out and yelling over the mess, I put the diaper back on and wait anywhere from 3 to 6 months, only letting the child try the toilet before baths. I remind myself, that it will happen at some point.
Here are a few of my experiences:
- My first child was young (before age two). It took quite a while to get her to understand what I wanted her to do. Once she understood, she was dry day and night after only a week. But she was so little that I had to help her in the bathroom for the next year and a half.
- Two of my kids knew exactly what to do, but were pretty stubborn and had daily accidents for about 4 months. I still kept them in underwear and continued potty training.
- One child was afraid to poop outside of a diaper. He would go five days and then poop his pants in a panic. After about 2 weeks, I took him to the store and said he could buy whatever he wanted, and let him know that he would not get it until he put his poop in the toilet. He chose a Hershey bar. He pooped in the toilet the next day and never had a problem after that.
- One child hid in her closet to poop and then tried to hide her poop or wipe it up with toys or towels. I could not handle the messes at all. Her diaper went back on. After 6 months I tried again, leaving her alone to do her stuff. She did it fine and only ever had one more accident.
I hope this helps. But, I have to say, potty training is very, very gross, and very hard. I know people who do pull-ups for a year. Really, I think whatever works best for you and your child.